Hello dear
Welcome To Red Key Tavern
Nestled at 5170 N College Ave in Indianapolis, Red Key Tavern embodies the quintessential local watering hole. Known for its cash-only policy, this charming dive offers a relaxed atmosphere perfect for enjoying a well-crafted cheeseburger or a satisfying BLT. With model planes adorning the ceiling and a friendly staff, the tavern exudes vintage charm that invites both nostalgia and comfort. Patrons rave about the quality of the food and drinks, with many highlighting the freshly prepared menu items. Whether you're stopping in for a cold beer or catching live music, Red Key Tavern is a must-visit for a good time.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
About
Red Key Tavern
Welcome to Red Key Tavern, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Broad Ripple, Indianapolis. This beloved local haunt is renowned for its quintessential pub vibe, where a love for great food and cold beer meets a nostalgic atmosphere. Just a stone’s throw away at 5170 N College Ave, the tavern exudes a charm that transports you to a simpler time, thanks in part to the playful model planes hanging from the ceiling.
What truly sets Red Key Tavern apart are its standout dishes, particularly the burgers. Locals rave about them, calling them some of the best in town, all thanks to the culinary wizardry of Sully. They are nothing short of a must-try for anyone seeking a hearty meal. The friendly staff eagerly ensures that your experience is enjoyable, providing genuine service that leaves a lasting impression.
For those looking for a casual spot to unwind after a long day, this tavern is an oasis of relaxation. The atmosphere is laid-back, inviting patrons to come as they are, whether stopping by for just a cold beer or a satisfying bite to eat. The BLT has garnered praise from regulars, while the cheeseburgers remain a fan favorite. There’s something wonderfully unpretentious about the menu; each item is made with care, ensuring a delightful culinary experience without any unnecessary frills.
Remember, Red Key Tavern operates on a cash-only basis, so make sure you’re prepared before heading in. The lively ambiance, punctuated by the occasional live music, makes it a fantastic spot for social gatherings or a simple drink with friends. It's a place where the old-timers know your name, and new faces are welcomed with open arms.
If you find yourself in Indianapolis, make sure to add Red Key Tavern to your itinerary. With remarkable burgers, a friendly atmosphere, and a sense of community that is hard to find, it's a place that promises to make you feel right at home.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Cash only. Amazing cheeseburger. A must visit. Friendly and unbelievable atmosphere. ”
“ A wonderful little bar with. Great service and selection of drinks. ”
“ No hookah here so disregard anything regarding that. Just your quintessential local watering hole and dive. No frills and the absolute perfect ambiance and vibe. Cold beer, affordable drinks and food (freshly prepared), and efficient service. Whether popping in by yourself for one or catching up with a group of friends while not wanting to go to an overly crowded bar, this is the spot. The real treat is when you are lucky to catch live music as well. Cash only so come prepared or hit the ATM inside. ”
“ An old tavern with lots of history. Cash only. This place has fair rules you must follow. The food menu is limited but their burgers are some of the best in town. ”
“ My new favorite pub in Indianapolis! I feel like I’m walking into the past. The staff is really friendly and genuinely wanted us to have a great time. We had the burgers and we’re not disappointed. ”
“ Fantastic little bar. The vibe is totally unique to the area and anywhere I’ve been in Indy. Very limited menu which is perfectly fine. Potato salad and burger is where it’s at. Classic little no frills bar. Will definitely be back! ”
“ These burgers are one of the best in town, only made by Sully. The atmosphere is great, love the model plans hanging from the ceiling. It is cash only so make sure you are prepared. ”
“ Really, chill spot to stop in for a simple beer and satisfying bite to eat! The few menu items available are really well made and yummy! Nothing fancy, just plain good! Great cheeseburgers! I personally enjoyed the BLT! I love the location and the staff is great! A lot of the Broad Ripple old timers know this low key casual spot .A relaxed and easy atmosphere! Highly recommend to add this stop to your out and about ! ”