Introducing the menu at Red Key Tavern is a delightful adventure for those who appreciate quality over quantity. Nestled at 5170 N College Ave, Indianapolis, this beloved pub is famous for its cash-only system, so come prepared! The true highlight here is the mouthwatering cheeseburger, praised by regulars like Todd Helmold and Douglas Moses as arguably the best in town, crafted by the talented Sully.
The menu may be modest, but each item is made with care, ensuring satisfying bites that resonate with patrons. Christiana Watson's recommendation of the BLT perfectly captures the essence of comfort food. The atmosphere is welcoming and relaxed, infused with a nostalgic vibe, making it a popular spot among Broad Ripple locals.
Red Key Tavern isn't just a place to grab a bite; it’s where great food, cold beer, and friendly service seamlessly come together for a genuine pub experience.
